Immunisation debate 2014. At the same time, the current and future benefits of the vaccine are much more difficult to imagine and process. Should states be allowed to mandate vaccines for school attendance? Learn the pros and cons of the debate. Where appropriate and feasible, vaccination information should be targeted to address beliefs about ethnic differences held by some individuals from some BAME backgrounds. Certainly there is a resounding call from the medical community for parents to conform. Prevaccine disease incidence was obtained from published data or Concerns over vaccine safety and/or the reporting of concerns over vaccine safety have polarised the immunisation debate and led to a loss of confidence among some parents and a consequent fall in immunisation coverage in some countries. Jan 8, 2014 · The situation is difficult when we have a new vaccine, in this case against meningitis B, but lack important evidence on its effectiveness. We’ll talk this hour about how politics and social concerns have directed medical policy with Emory University assistant history professor Elena Conis. Nov 9, 2023 · Background By mid 2023, European countries reached 75% of vaccine coverage for COVID-19 and although vaccination rates are quite high, many people are still hesitant. As pediatric practitioners, one of the contemporary challenges in providing medical care for children is the increasing proportion of vaccination refusal. Published: 2/10/2015 Comments LANSING - According to the Center for Disease Control (CDC), measles is making a comeback in the U. 1. Abstract In this article, I take up one strand – arguably the central one – of the Foucault/Habermas debate: their respective accounts of subjectivation. 04% of one year olds had been Jul 1, 2015 · Recent events have re-energized the ongoing debate about mandatory vaccines for children in the U. Apr 29, 2015 · Immunization rates in Virginia are very good according to the Virginia Department of Health. The large number of infant and childhood deaths was strongly linked to many diseases that are now under control with infant and childhood vaccination programs. Go further into this topic with The Vaccine War Lesson Plan, which models how disease spreads in a Jan 13, 2011 · Dr. A panel of experts he appointed will no longer recommend annual flu shots that contain it. To provide a closer look at both sides of the immunization debate, here are a few pros and cons of vaccines. However, the larger debate must also address practical and logistical issues when applying immunization requirements through public policy. In 1956, a vaccination program against polio began and was so successful that Interventions that have contributed the most to improved health and longevity since the beginning of the twentieth century have been the public health measures of sanitation; clean water sources; and researched, implemented vaccination programs. It is imperative we learn lessons from this debate so we are better positioned to navigate policy proposals for mandatory vaccination in the future. But in the light of declining vaccine take up in recent years, both in the UK and elsewhere, there is a debate today about the best way to ensure the greatest levels of immunisation amongst populations. Feb 24, 2021 · Introduction to Childhood Vaccinations in Australia During the 20 th century, approximately one in ten children did not survive beyond their first birthday. As students head off to learn math, science, and history, parents learn that their Jun 17, 2014 · There has been enormous debate regarding the possibility of a link between childhood vaccinations and the subsequent development of autism. We use persuasion, not coercion. This occurs in spite of the demonstrated individual and collective benefit and cost effectiveness of vaccination. com. Immunisation Debate By the time a child is only a few months old, they are expected to be immunised with a concoction of vaccinations, including those for hepatitis, diphtheria and polio. Both studies are critically flawed. down the path of questioning vaccine safety. Specifically, we should aim to dispense with unsophisticated ethical School & Child Care Immunization Vaccination efforts by school and public health officials, immunization providers, and parents are key to the success of protecting our children and communities from vaccine preventable diseases. First study In 1998, Andrew Wakefield and colleagues published a paper in the journal The Lancet. with 600 cases in 2014 and 121 so far this year. au Immunisation debate no jab no play no jab no stay for new migrants coming to australia Like Comment Share May 22, 2014 · Mandating school entry vaccinations is contentious with different laws in place across Canada's provinces and territories. Discussion It is argued that removing the deterrent effect – the We propose a long-term approach to overcome vaccine hesitancy that involves the education of children and adolescents on the basics about immunization and critical thinking, using different communication channels. by James Heiser Jan 28, 2020 · Two experts debate whether making vaccinations compulsory for school-age children could be the answer to improving coverage. This attention has only increased in light of the coronavirus pandemic, with public May 31, 2025 · The resurgence of the vaccine–autism debate raises important ethical and policy questions, particularly regarding whether public health science should entertain conspiracy-driven demands to re-evaluate disproven hypotheses. Many vaccine-related ethical debates center on the evidence that access to vaccination depends in some way on socioeconomic and racial ethnic minority status. Folks who use those arguments against vaccines aren’t debating, they are pushing anti-vaccine talking points. The Wakefield studies Two studies were cited early on by those claiming that the MMR vaccine causes autism. Say the word "immunization" and watch parents get hot. According to data from 2010 to 2014, rates have been ABOVE 92% in all reported categories. It is true that many illnesses confer future immunity to those who get them. Kennedy, Jr. Her new book is Vaccine Nation: America’s Changing Relationship with Immunization. Using fallacious arguments and anti-vaccine propaganda can not be part of any real debate about vaccines. A plethora of studies have investigated factors associated with COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy, however, insufficient attention has been paid to the reasons why people get vaccinated against COVID-19. As history has This paper evaluates and reviews the origins of the anti-vaccination movement, the reasons behind the recent strengthening of the movement, role of the internet in the spread of anti-vaccination ideas, and the repercussions in terms of public health and safety. School Vaccine Mandates - 1-minute Survey: After reading this debate, take our quick survey to see how this information affected your opinion of this topic. What’s not up for debate anymore is the idea that vaccines aren’t safe or necessary or that vaccines don’t work. 2 The reduction in morbidity and mortality over the past century as a result of routine childhood immunizations is quite dramatic. This has in recent times become a major public health issue with vaccine preventable diseases increasing in the community due to the fear of a ‘link’ between vaccinations and autism. We provide a discussion on the appeal of anti-vaccine sentiments from a psychological, historical, and philosophical point of view Say the word "immunization" and watch parents get hot. Two reviewers extracted data on study characteristics, methods, and outcomes. How do you choose the right thing to do to keep your child well? Jun 25, 2025 · All childhood vaccines in question after first meeting of RFK Jr. The Since the development of the first U. Our work aims to investigate the Jan 31, 2022 · Home Health pros and cons The pros and cons of compulsory vaccination Government reviewing policy to mandate Covid vaccines for frontline NHS staff The pro- vs anti-vaccine discussion has gained traction in the light of the recent COVID-19 pandemic. Introduction The suboptimal uptake of COVID-19 vaccines in many parts of the world has prompted unprecedented public debate concerning the ethics of mandatory vaccination [1]. We provide a discussion on the appeal of anti-vaccine sentiments from a psychological, historical, and philosophical point of view "There is a great deal of evidence to prove that immunisation of children does more harm than good. Specifically, we should aim to dispense with unsophisticated ethical Conclusions Factors related to ethnicity must be considered when seeking to understand immunisation decisions among parents from BAME backgrounds. One of these is vaccination, or immunisation. ’s vaccine panel Overall, the meeting was packed with anti-vaccine talking points and arguments. And that increase in immunization is not without its critics. We need to know how well the vaccine will protect, how long it will protect for and whether it will stop the bacteria spreading from person to person. But for one in five Colorado kindergarteners, there was no immunization information on record for the 2014-15 school Nov 2, 2014 · Navarro-Illano and colleagues published a thought-provoking summary debate regarding the ethical considerations of universal vaccination against HPV in 2014 since the country of Spain was considering the adoption of an HPV vaccine program (31). How do you choose the right thing to do to keep your child well? We all want the best for our children. Last Feb 26, 2016 · Colorado passed a bill two years ago to have schools report vaccination rates. All of the major health organizations currently recommend that infants and children be vaccinated against 14 communicable diseases. Peter A. Oct 29, 2021 · In the United States—where vaccines are widely available—about 23% of eligible individuals have chosen to not get a jab. But to get that immunity, patients first have to s … Critique of vaccination policy and practice has a long history, and social scientists and others have devoted significant efforts to understanding this phenomenon. James Dobson hosts 'Family Talk' to empower families with Biblical wisdom on parenting, marriage, and cultural issues that affect today’s families. As doctors call for parents to immunise their kids, we take a look at the debate surrounding vaccination. I requested this debate following the JCVI’s decision on the 2 October 2013 to undertake further work on key issues surrounding the human papillomavirus, or HPV, vaccination programme. In our discussion we review the anti-vaccine movement in its current state, including associated demographics, argumentative patterns, and putative developments. “There is no debate,” says Alison Gaylard, from the Northern Rivers Vaccination Supporters Group, an area with one of the lowest rates of immunisation in Australia. 2018 saw a record number of vaccinations, with statistics from the Australian Health Department stating that approximately 94. Apr 5, 2025 · Vaccination remains the most cost-effective public health intervention, preventing millions of deaths and reducing disease burden worldwide. The human papillomavirus (HPV) is a prevalent sexually transmitted infection with certain strains linked to cervical and other types of cancers. 1 However, their impact is rendered meaningless if vaccines are not epidemiologically relevant to the populations they serve, are not accepted by communities, or are not effectively delivered through routine or mass immunisation programmes. Nov 30, 2015 · Controversy continues to swirl around vaccinations, despite scientific consensus that they are safe and effective. Mendelsohn, Author and Professor of Paediatrics (How To Raise The mere mention of immunisation is enough to get an immediate reaction. Apr 1, 2002 · Vaccination is the only type of medical intervention that has eliminated a disease successfully. Keywords: vaccination, mmr vaccine, measles outbreak, virus, anti-vaccine movement Mar 1, 2020 · One persistent anti-vaccine argument goes like this: Getting a disease gives a person stronger or longer-lasting "natural" immunity to that illness than taking the vaccine. The following content will cover the basics of the vaccine debate. Apr 18, 2015 · Here is a specialists view on the immunisation debate. We characterize the public-health impact of vaccination by providing updated estimates of disease incidence with and without universally recommended pediatric vaccines. In the view of some, there is no question; we should simply follow the recommendations. Discussion It is argued that removing the deterrent effect – the While rare side effects can occur with any vaccine, the benefits of protecting your dog from life-threatening diseases far outweigh any potential risks. The ongoing controversy around vaccination uptake has left many Americans on opposite sides of a fiery debate which has significant implications for public health. May 13, 2015 · Kristin Cavallari’s latest pregnancy announcement has once again placed the spotlight on the celebrity’s controversial anti-vaccination stance. A sweeping review by the McCullough Foundation reseachers claims vaccines are a key modifiable autism risk — but does the data justify the conclusion? Nicolas Hulscher, MPH, along with co-authors Dr. Wakefield's hypothesis was that the measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine caused a series of events that include intestinal inflammation, entrance into New data shows that vaccination is at its lowest rates in the wealthiest suburbs - but what does our panel think? http://bit. Vaccination, despite being recognized as one of the most effective primary public health measures, is viewed as unsafe and unnecessary by an increasing number of individuals. Vaccination is paraded as medicine’s greatest Oct 21, 2021 · We asked Aronowitz, a professor in the Department of History and Socology of Science and co-editor of Three Shots at Prevention: The HPV Vaccine and the Politics of Medicine’s Simple Solutions, his thoughts on how vaccine hesitancy today compares to the past, the politicization of public health, and the power of vaccination mandates. GREEN BAY- Health professionals say with recent increases in cases of measles and mumps, it's important to vaccinate your children. S. However, both in countries with high immunization rates and in countries that are too impoverished Apr 7, 2014 · Background From an epidemiological perspective, the practice of universal vaccination of girls and young women in order to prevent human papilloma virus (HPV) infection and potential development of cervical cancer is widely accepted even though it may lead to the neglect of other preventive strategies against cervical cancer. Mar 19, 2025 · In 1971, the FDA approved the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine, which combined three vaccines that had been approved previously—in 1963, 1967, and 1969, respectively. The vaccine inventors, Salk and Saban, were hailed as heroes when in reality, there is no reasonable evidence that their polio vaccination had much to do with the success of eradicating the disease at all. But there are still parents who fear the vaccinations themselves The topic of measles vaccinations has become a full-on debate, with the president and political figures speaking out about whether or not the recent measles outbreak signals a need for stricter Jan 31, 2022 · Home Health pros and cons The pros and cons of compulsory vaccination Government reviewing policy to mandate Covid vaccines for frontline NHS staff The pro- vs anti-vaccine discussion has gained traction in the light of the recent COVID-19 pandemic. We appreciate your feedback. While parents are right to demand the safety of any vaccine, medication, or other medical treatment being recommended for their children, it is important to understand the wide-reaching benefits of immunization. To sort the science from the news, an interdisciplinary group of experts from the Yale faculty held a discussion during the AYA Assembly, held on November 19. . Successful mobilization by vaccine critics during Though many consider vaccination a top public health achievement of modern medicine, opposition to vaccination dates back to its introduction in the early 1800s. As these outbreaks continue, controversy hovers over Ingham County on whether vaccinating children should be mandatory or not. They're either for it or against it. Mar 24, 2025 · The House defeated Senate Bill 460, relating to vaccine requirements, in a 42-56 vote Monday afternoon after more than two hours of debate with just under three weeks left in the 2025 legislative Mar 1, 2020 · One persistent anti-vaccine argument goes like this: Getting a disease gives a person stronger or longer-lasting "natural" immunity to that illness than taking the vaccine. Here we will discuss these issues with lessons learned from applying vaccine mandates to a military population that required full vaccination of all personnel. May 22, 2014 · Mandating school entry vaccinations is contentious with different laws in place across Canada's provinces and territories. Though many consider vaccination a top public health achievement of modern medicine, opposition to vaccination dates back to its introduction in the early 1800s. Dec 5, 2021 · Historically, immunisation campaigns have seen huge success, eradicating smallpox and drastically reducing mortality levels in diseases such as polio and measles. Implicit in these discussions is whether all lives are equal, and equally deserving of opportunities to be protected by vaccination. Food and Drug Administration–approved vaccine for the prevention of serious disease and death associated with the SARS-CoV-2 virus, health care workers have been expected to comply with mandatory immunization Jun 27, 2025 · The preservative thimerosal started Robert F. Nov 14, 2014 · Eula Biss' examination of the vaccination debate "On Immunity — An Inoculation" is not immune to criticism. There is a lot of emotion out there on both sides. ly/1hYA8LYmore Watch the video clip and start a discussion that examines the debate over childhood vaccination. Introduction Preventive care is the cornerstone of pediatrics, and vaccination represents one of the most important strategies in the prevention of disease in children. Illinois State Board of Education (ISBE) immunization status data for DuPage County students in grades K-12 in public and non-public schools during the 2014–15 school year shows that less than two percent of students were unvaccinated or under-vaccinated. Sadly, there was even a steep rise in polio at one point due to a bad batch of vaccinations. Mention the word ‘debate’ in the same sentence and you’re likely to be met with a heated response. Find the resources you need on this page, including information about state regulations, recommendations, and consent forms. Smallpox has been totally eradicated, and other infectious diseases are on the verge of elimination, if responsible immunization is practiced. The Jun 27, 2025 · The preservative thimerosal started Robert F. Nov 29, 2020 · The postmodern medical paradigm is becoming increasingly relevant to vaccine communication. Anxiety about vaccines and vaccination programs leading to vaccine Jan 8, 2014 · New vaccination programmes and extensions to existing programmes represent a significant cost to the health service in terms of both vaccine procurement and administration. For pet owners concerned about specific vaccine components (like thimerosal), discuss alternatives with your veterinarian, though these options may be less readily available and more costly. Government and health authorities pushing a pro-vaccine position oft Apr 20, 2022 · A recent study suggests that vaccine hesitancy amongst key demographics – including females, younger individuals, and certain ethnic groups – could undermine the pursuit of herd immunity against CO Aug 22, 2022 · BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES. Research has shown that vaccine related knowledge varies substantially by HCP discipline, with a wide variability in immunization curriculum [10, 18, 21, 22]. The ProCon staff used the following resources for this feature: CDC, “Your child needs vaccines as they grow!” cdc. Leake, MA, and collaborators including Andrew Wakefield, MBBS, published the 82-page report “Determinants of Autism Spectrum Disorder”. Jan 8, 2014 · I am grateful to Mr Speaker for granting this debate on the work of the Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation. Mar 17, 2017 · Social media, celebrities, an antiscience mood, and rage against pharmaceutical companies keep the debate alive over whether vaccines are safe for children. Moreover, while the pro-vaccine gatekeepers were non-governmental organisations or health professionals, the anti-vaccine ones were activists and/or parents. Smallpox has been globally eradicated, while diseases such as diphtheria, polio, and congenital Stay up to date on getting recommended vaccines for you and your family. Please read as part of gaining knowledge. Keywords: immunization, vaccine hesitancy, critical thinking, health education, children Introduction While rare side effects can occur with any vaccine, the benefits of protecting your dog from life-threatening diseases far outweigh any potential risks. But over the last decade more people have objected to Mar 23, 2014 · With skepticism of authority growing, forcing immunization may create martyrs. But in 1998, a paper Jan 29, 2025 · Robert F. Current routine immunizations for children aged ≤10 years in the United States in 2019 cover 14 vaccine-preventable diseases. Mar 23, 2014 · An outbreak of measles in Manhattan showed that even doctors had overlooked the disease as childhood vaccination became widespread. Immigration and Citizenship Australia · April 30, 2014 · migrationalliance. While screening and behavioural interventions play important roles in prevention, vaccination has been shown to provide superior The pro-vaccine users, instead, formed a fragmented network, with loose but strategic connections that facilitated networking and the distribution of new vaccine information. Sep 9, 2014 · This article examines trends in state-level childhood vaccine policies in the United States from 1998 to 2012 and explains the trajectories for both vaccine-critical and proimmunization legislative efforts. Controversies regarding vaccine … Nov 25, 2014 · Today’s American children are the most-vaccinated generation in history. It remains to be seen which side of the controversy will prevail. Oct 15, 2024 · A simplistic explanation, such as the claim that the emerging but still weak immune system of the toddler is overstimulated and damaged by the vaccine, adds credibility to the cause-effect sequence. Pros: Mar 22, 2025 · Learn about the difference between vaccination recommendations vs. Against those who hold that Foucault and Habermas occupy such drastically different theoretical perspectives as to preclude the integration of their views into a common framework, I begin to lay the groundwork for an account of Apr 7, 2014 · Background From an epidemiological perspective, the practice of universal vaccination of girls and young women in order to prevent human papilloma virus (HPV) infection and potential development of cervical cancer is widely accepted even though it may lead to the neglect of other preventive strategies against cervical cancer. 's nomination to lead HHS reflects the rising power of an anti-vaccination movement more than 100 years in the making. From time to time we are faced with burdensome decisions concerning their wellbeing. " Dr J Anthony Morris, former Chief Vaccine Control Officer, US Food and Drug Administration "The greatest threat of childhood disease lies in the dangerous and ineffectual efforts made to prevent them through mass immunisation. gov (accessed Dec, 12, 2024) Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, "All Timelines Overview 2019 2019 October – A Sweet Story from a Parent of a Diabetic Camper 2019 May – Camps Are Not Immune to the Immunization Debate The controversy surrounding the safety of coronavirus disease-19 vaccinations is part of a larger historical backdrop of ongoing discussions regarding vaccine safety that have spanned several decades. The historical disputes around measles, mumps, Dec 1, 2024 · The discussion surrounding the ethics of mandatory HPV vaccination for young adolescents aged 12–13 is complex. " Dr R. McCullough (MD, MPH), John S. mandates, plus get info on the importance of following a vaccination schedule. Jul 2, 2019 · Internationally, various studies have been undertaken to assess immunization knowledge and attitudes of future HCPs [10, 18, 21, 22]. Jun 17, 2014 · Eligible studies assessed the relationship between vaccine administration and the subsequent development of autism or autism spectrum disorders (ASD). Obviously, it is essential that any recommendations from the JCVI on changes to the national vaccination programme are supported by evidence of cost-effectiveness. The vaccine has proven safe and effective and has been widely administered around the world for decades. METHODS. The bill to centralize immunization data at the state Health Department, instead of at school districts, passed a Democratic House committee late Thursday on a 7-6 vote after hours of impassioned testimony Feb 26, 2016 · An attempt to better track vaccination rates in Colorado is moving ahead in the state Legislature - but it’s doubtful the effort will make it to the governor’s desk. Jan 19, 2018 · Sure. The former “The Hills” star and her husband, Chicago Bears quarterback Jay Cutler, recently announced they are expecting their third child. Kennedy Jr. 6vjmw llgr 9p ucu 9ebsn nwi4m ez 6rb5n8 qb62o qtga